google
yahoo
bing

17 People Who Created the Word of Mouth Industry

November 23rd, 2009

In 2004, Pete Blackshaw, Jonathan Carson and Dave Balter (yeah, that’s me) founded the Word of Mouth Marketing Association.  Our goal was to help our industry grow by setting ethical and measurement standards.  We knew almost nothing about associations, but we were adept at building businesses and had passion to beat the band

Last week, at the Paris Hotel in Las Vegas, the Association held its annual conference and nearly 500 people chatted, shook hands, reconnected, learned something and generally got their Vegas on.   The rise of Social Media and the FTC’s updated Endorsement Guides were the major themes of the event, and provided plenty of fodder for discussion and debate.

A rolling boulder collects no moss…and these early WOMMA characters are no different.  Here’s where these early industry innovators were then and where they are now …

Who Then Now
Pete Blackshaw (@peteblackshaw) I mean, this guy needs no intro, but back then he was a big brain at Intelliseek.  Pete and I started egging each other on to develop WOMMA during a prep session for an Ad-Tech panel. Ok, so Intelliseek merged with BuzzMetrics, then they got bought by Nielsen.  Yeah, that’s pretty cool.   New fact from this conference:  Pete can go to bed at 1 AM, only to wake at 3 AM in a fit of note-taking and memo-writing.
Dr. Walter Carl (@doctorwom) The non-nutty Northeastern professor who started experimenting with proving the reach of offline word of mouth conversations. Now those early Northeastern experiments are the foundation of Chat Threads, an incredible platform that helps companies measure the results of word of mouth and social media initiatives.
Jackie Huba (@jackiehuba) & Ben McConnell (@benmcconnell) Yeah, they wrote the incredible, Creating Customer Evangelists and Jackie spent some time on the WOMMA Board. Both are wicked smart. Now joining forces with Sean O’Driscoll, Jake McKee and Sean McDonald to continue to build Ant’s Eye View, which plays at the intersection of customer engagement and social technologies. The whole crew has a cone of creativity you need to get inside.
Max Kalehoff (@maxkalehoff) PR genius with BuzzMetrics (now Neilsen Online), who helped WOMMA really craft its messaging. Plus he has cool glasses and a big smile. Sharp-as-hell tack at Clickable, continuing to ask the questions that need to be asked, and more often than not, giving us the answers.  Big smile still big.
Brad Fay and Ed Keller Ed wrote the Influentials while still at Roper NOP, where Brad and he were gainfully employed.  Ed pontificated often that this Word of Mouth stuff had big potential for the rapidly evolving research industry. Now run Keller Fay Group, a pre-eminent Word of Mouth research firm, and Ed was even President of WOMMA for a few years. Fun fact: Ed was home sick and didn’t make this event, but Brad showed up and someone even called him Ed.  I mean, they are hard to confuse.
Steve Knox (@trav1955) Steve ran the show at P&G’s Tremor, a teen-based Word of Mouth network that eventually added Vocalpoint, which focused on Moms.  Nothing said success more than P&G, one of the world’s greatest marketers, establishing its own business in this space. Tremor/Vocalpoint continues to break new ground with its methodology.  They’re now an outstanding member of WOMMA, and Steve is still running the show.  And this guy can present to be the band:  At this most recent conference he delivered a case on Kashi that was one of the most inspiring, thoughtful – and talked about – moments of the event.
Owen Mack & Jesse Buckley (@cobrandit) The guys behind Co-Brandit were yapping to us about video before anyone cared, including us.  They hung around a lot, and we thought they were either crackpots, or this video stuff might just have a future. Well, video seems to have made it. Co-Brandit has since filmed every single WOMMA event, giving them the only true historical record of the industry’s growth.  They’re still doing amazing social media video production.  Unknown cool fact: these dudes are cousins.
John Moore (@wommajohn) The dude who wrote awesome blog posts at Brand Autopsy about evangelism and advocacy, said what needed to be said, and never ever pulled a single punch Now officially part of the WOMMA crew, providing marketing leadership.  Still blogging, thinking and not even close to pulling punches. Plus he wears a mean lab coat.
Dave Reis (@davidreis) Dave is the guy behind DEI.  He was in the room when we pulled that first group together and was the consummate cheerleader. DEI is still kicking it, big time.  Dave wore the nicest pinstripe suit at the whole event.  Really.
Emmanuel Rosen (@emmanuelrosen) Emmanuel wrote the Anatomy of Buzz, a book that laid the foundation for many future Word of Mouth businesses, including BzzAgent. The revised edition of Anatomy of Buzz is out now (everyone got a copy in their bag); it’s an even better read than the first and updates word of mouth for the social media era
Todd Steinman (@tsteinman) Todd was one of the M80 boys, alongside Jeff Semones and Dave Neupert – they were in the room when started talking about organizing the industry.  True fact: most of the M80 folks were a lot hipper than rest of us. As an early pioneer in the digital Word of Mouth landscape, it’s no wonder WPP’s Group M decided to buy them a few years back.  They’re now evolving deeply into social media. They’re still pretty cool.
Jamie Tedford (@jamietedford) Jamie has great hair. It’s true, and that gave him some mad presence.  Jamie led Arnold into the Word of Mouth industry, extolling the need for agencies to get smart about medium, long before many were wise to it. Now Jamie is CEO of Brand Networks, a marketing company that helps “socialize” brands….Jamie sat on WOMMA’s board for a term,  and he still has great hair.
Bob Troia (@bobtroia) & Warren Ackerman (@warrenackerman) Bob and Warren ran Fanpimp, which developed online fan communities mainly for the entertainment industry. At the time the debate was whether this was the new ‘street team’ or guerrilla marketing or actually Word of Mouth. Fanpimp eventually evolved into Affinitive, an amazing brand community platform with a suite of tools to manage, monitor and engage social media advocacy.  Don’t let them fool you though:  These guys have plenty of fans, and they’re still pimps (in the best way possible, of course).

It was a hazy few days…that’s all I remember.  Congrats, BTW, to the entire WOMMA team for pulling this event together.  Truly exceptional work… Read the rest of this entry »

  • Share/Bookmark


CEO Wanted to Scratch an Itch

November 12th, 2009

So, I’ve got this incredible, market-making, revolutionary idea.  I need a CEO to run with it.

I have ideas all the time, but this is one of the special ones.  One that makes you drop everything else to make it a reality.   But, the thing is, my day job as CEO of BzzAgent keeps me pretty busy, and it’s not droppable.

So, if you’ve been a CEO – or haven’t been, but should be – I wanna talk to you.  Here’s the criteria:

  • I don’t care what school you went to or how old you are.  I’m ok with MBA, PHD or high school degree.
  • Experience in the real world is good, but not necessary.  Experience with a successful startup is valuable.  Experience with failure is a huge plus.
  • You must have the drive and energy to make this a reality.  9-5 doesn’t cut it, and the clock won’t stop.
  • Your charisma needs to magnetize people around you, and attract them like moths to a flame.
  • I want to see pinwheels in your eyes when you get excited about an idea.  If clients, friends, consumers don’t see that, it will never work.
  • This is a startup, which we’re going to build without “trying to fund it” first.  That means little cash, but lotsa upside.
  • You’ll have to deal with me.  That can be fun, inspiring and annoying all at once.

I will say no to a lot of people.  If you’re one of them, don’t take it personally.  I can’t tell you who will be perfect, but I’ll know it when I see it.

You ready?  Go!

scratch1

  • Share/Bookmark


Dave Balter Fall 2009 Speaking Gig Slides and Cliffnotes

November 9th, 2009

With social media rapidly revolutionizing the concept of Word of Mouth, it’s time for a new speech iteration…

And for those who want follow up, here’s the cliffnote version of weblinks to the ideas/videos…(I know you just want to buy a Man Groomer…)

  • Share/Bookmark


7 of Joe Chernov’s Proverbs (Chernovisms)

November 2nd, 2009

Joe Chernov’s last day at BzzAgent is tomorrow.

As  our VP of Communications, Joe has had such an incredible impact on this business, it’s hard to put it down on paper.  Joe joined this company to do PR, first as a contractor and then as a full timer.   And PR was his sole focus for 3.5 years – during a stint that the business that was truly a PR juggernaut.  (2008 was especially crazed with hits with CBS, and a book release.)

But when our VP of Marketing left in early 2009, a vacuum was created in marketing and we asked Joe to fill it – which he did, admirably.  But Joe’s career plan was never marketing. It was always PR.  We talked throughout, and ultimately he let me know that he was going to return to his PR roots elsewhere.  As much as I didn’t want to lose a member of the BzzAgent family, Joe’s been such a meaningful contributor that I didn’t want to get in his way.

People who know Joe, know that his capabilities with words are unparalleled.  Daily duties called for him to wear dozens of hats, including writing press releases, copyediting my articles, manage external relationships, and creating clear internal communications.  And often, he would make the most complicated situation clear by his knack for delivering pithy proverbs…or analogies…or allegories…or metaphors…approprisims…or whatever they may be called (Joe would probably know).  A few weeks back I started keeping a list of these so people could get a flavor.  Note that he’d toss these out off-the-cuff, spur-of-the-moment, without so much blinking an eye.  Here’s a handful.

  • Put me in coach, I don’t need a helmet…leads to concussions sometimes
  • [a non profit org] are separatists — they are the Montreal of associations
  • The shorter the hair, the more frequent the cut.  (to illustrate a counter intuitive outcome)
  • Getting ready for the birth of a baby is like Christmas shopping, you are never really done…
  • When elephants fight, the grass loses.
  • When you let the bull out of the barn, you’re responsible for all the damage the bull does.
  • What’s the sound of one hand clapping?

Any staffers have others to add to the list?

Anyway, Joe…thanks for all that you did for BzzAgent.

We’ll truly miss you, and remember – if you can find a path with no obstacles, it probably doesn’t lead anywhere.

  • Share/Bookmark


9 Things I Learned from Reed Hastings @ Netflix

October 24th, 2009

At a private CEO event a few weeks back, I had the pleasure of seeing Reed give a powerpoint-less presentation.   His way of looking at business is quite inspirational, and there’s now doubt it’s a major reason why Netflix succeeded where many others have not.  I’ve been thinking about which of these ideas fit for BzzAgent…regardless, every company could add a little bit of his wisdom.  Here’s what I jotted down (note much of this is paraphrased):

  1. When outlining a strategy, instead of just articulating what you’re going to do, always add what you’re NOT going to do.   To know what your strategy will force you to not do will make things much clearer.
  2. If you can grow within your market by 10x, then stay in that market.  If you can’t grow by 10 times, then expand into other markets where you can.
  3. Companies aren’t like families.  Families provide unconditional love and are highly dysfunctional.  Companies, rather, are high performance teams.  Sports teams make their players try out for their job every year.  If you need a great left tackle, you shouldn’t just keep someone because they were there last year.
  4. A great company is not sushi at lunch; it’s working with incredible people.
  5. Don’t optimize for people who follow process, optimize for people who think and are mavericks.  Flexibility is more important than efficiency.
  6. Coordinate team on strategy but avoid buy0in on tactics.  Think: Highly aligned, loosely coupled.   Occasionally stuff goes wrong, but this allows for much better speed to execution.
  7. Managers need to ween selves from crutch of an employee’s time in seat vs how they’re succeeding.
  8. If a smart person does something dumb, figure out the problem in the context that you set, not the tactic that they failed at.
  9. Value is what you hire and fire on.  Forget the bs flowery stuff.  Your values are based on what makes you decide to hire someone.

When I caught up with Reed after his speaking gig, we talked a little bit about some of his other ideas on compensation.  I’m not sure I buy into those yet, but he’s got me thinking…

reed_hastings_netflix
Reed Hastings, CEO of Netflix

  • Share/Bookmark


Pimping that CEO of Hubspot, Brian Halligan

October 22nd, 2009

Brian and his Hubspot co-founder Dharmesh, wrote a great book called Inbound Marketing…it’s well worth the read.

Hubspot is one of the hottest companies floating around Boston right now,  and are helping define the future of social media (in some ways, they remind me of BzzAgent circa 2005-2006 — they’ve got that mad type of mojo right now).

As one of Brian’s buddies, I figured I’d ask him a few questions to provide some Inbound Marketing-like exposure – and help him move a few units.

  1. What is Inbound Marketing and why should anyone pay attention to it?
  2. It used to be that you could efficiently grow your businesses by interrupting potential customers with outbound marketing methods like cold calls, email spam, advertising, etc.  Today, people and businesses are tired of being marketed to and are getting better and better atbrian halligan blocking marketing interruptions out.  At the same time, people and businesses have fundamentally changed the way they shop and learn turning more and more to Google, social media sites, and blogs to find what they want.  Inbound Marketing helps companies take advantage of these shifts to help companies get found by customers in the natural way in which they shop and learn

  3. You built a nifty tool to track amazon sales of the book.  Why and how is it representative of what Inbound Marketing is all about?
  4. It turns out that for an author, Amazon is a killer application and is the target of deep obsession.  There are two things in particular that are interesting to authors on their Amazon page.  First, Amazon tracks your “ranking” relative to the millions of other authors who have books for sale with folks like Dan Brown holding positions near the top.  The better your book is selling, the lower your ranking.  It is a little hard to figure the ranking out and how often the update it, so it is tempting to go to Amazon every 30 seconds and hit refresh.  Rather than do that, we build book.grader.com which tells you what your ranking is at all times, sends you an email alert when your ranking breaks a new record, lets you track your ranking via graph over time for your book and other books side-by-side.  Second, you want to see how many and know when you you got a new review of your book.  If you poured your soul into your book over gallons of hot cocoa, you hope/pray that people actually like the thing.  So, BookGrader tracks how many reviews you got and alerts you via email when you get a new one.At HubSpot, we help people “get found” in Google, blog, and social media.  BookGrader is a toe in the water of helping folks “get found” in Amazon.  If you are an author, check it out — its free!

  5. Tell us about the writing process – what worked, what didn’t and is it true you wrote the whole thing in your boxers?
  6. I wrote the book with my co-founder, Dharmesh Shah.  We put together an outline and split it up 50-50.  Despite the fact that we had most of the book in our heads from our work at HubSpot, it still was a huge amount of work on top of our day jobs.  My first step into the process was on a weekend away in Stowe where I locked myself inside at the Topnotch resort by the fireplace downing cup after cup of hot cocoa and cranked out about a third of it that weekend.  The rest was done in spurts over nights and weekends.  It turns out writing a book is hard to do in little bites — you need to get the whole thing straight in your head before you write, so you need some quality time.  Wrt boxers, yes I am a boxers man (as opposed to briefs), but I wrote most of it in sweatpants.

inboundmarketing

  • Share/Bookmark


A post about 20×200 or the FTC?

October 21st, 2009

Kottke says it all

In full disclosure, I read Jason’s blog.  Your reactions to his blog may not be the same as my reactions.  Make sure you tell people that if you tell them about this post about Jason’s blog.

  • Share/Bookmark


How big is big? How fast is fast?

October 15th, 2009

The big news these days in the world of marketing is that social media is the “next big thing” and it’s growing fast. But how big? How fast?

Enter this simple flash app that I came across recently that provides an active and dynamic representation of just how big and fast the social media world is growing. The general story is that social media, and everything that goes along with it like spending, is growing so fast that it’s now impossible to dismiss the power of it. It’s clear the days of thinking that this is a fad are over and social media is here to stay. For a long, long time.

So how does a company like BzzAgent fit in? Well, the super simple answer is this: we adapt. Notice I didn’t say we change. What BzzAgent is and has been is a powerful and effective tool that has shown it’s viability in the marketing world. Now we just need to move forward so we evolve what we you do to ensure that BzzAgent remains a leader. In the coming weeks we’ll discuss more about what I’m talking about.

Oh and here’s the tool to see how fast social media is growing.

Jono

  • Share/Bookmark


The Last Laugh from Justin Siegel at MocoSpace

October 14th, 2009

Ok, so here’s how this went down.

Last Summer our communications group worked with Cannes to set up a social media panel at their International Advertising Festival in June.  Part of the gig was that the BzzAgent CEO would sit on the panel (me) and we’d help find other participants to join.   We rallied a few folks from places like MySpace, Ford — and Justin Siegel at Mocospace.

f-mocospaceI ran into Justin shortly thereafter and we talked about the panel.  We were both griping that the folks at Cannes weren’t paying for speaker’s fees, or even travel, and to make matters worse, were charging us a few thousand bucks to attend the conference.  They also assigned our panel on a Sunday, meaning we’d have to fly out on a Saturday, ruining our weekends, etc.  We figured we’d at least have a good time together in France…

Then, I had to cancel for family reasons.  This happened shortly after Ford bailed, and then MySpace changed up their attendee from a big heavy hitter to someone out of Europe we’d never heard of.  I never spoke to Justin about it, but always wondered if he was cursing my name for signing him up for this boondoggle without the boon or the doggle.

Fast forward to last month – I was asked by the AdClub to arrange a panel on community, and invited Justin to be a part of it.  Other attendees included Jason Jacobs CEO of RunKeeper (awesome guy) and Ben Fischman CEO of Rue-La-La (also an awesome guy), moderated by Paul Gillin (social media guru, solid dude all around); I figured with the group we’d collected, this was a solid makeup for the Cannes issue.

This morning, as attendees munched bacon and slurped orange juice, we waited for Justin to show.  We neared launch time, and reached out to him via email – he wrote back something vague about waking up late.  We, of course, thought that was weird — for the CEO of a company to just not show for a panel that he was heavily promoted for.

Then it struck me: maybe, just maybe, this was Justin’s payback.  I mentioned it to Ben and Jason, and we all got an incredible kick out of it. Ben and I giggled about it through the panel.   It was something straight of Seinfeld, or even Curb Your Enthusaism.  Pure Genius.  I wish I’d thought of doing this…

To Justin, if you truly overslept, don’t tell me.  Let me live with the joy of knowing you maybe had the last laugh at my expense.  I would respect you even more for it.

  • Share/Bookmark


How to Sell

October 12th, 2009

Every week, dozens of vendors call or email me to try to sell me something I just can’t do without.  This year, more than 50% of my time is put into selling either directly to clients, or as wing to our own salesforce, analysts and media planners.  All of this serves as a reminder that sales is an instinctual profession: you either have it or you don’t.  Here’s what my instincts tell me:

  1. Respond With Stunning Speed (RWSS).  Be superhuman in your timing. When you get an email, write back within seconds; a call should be answered on the first ring. This isn’t high school, so forget about playing too busy and ‘hard to get’.
  2. Always Set a Schedule (ASS!).  When you want to talk with someone, suggest a firm time. Don’t say, “whenever is good for you,” or “how about we talk next week.”  Lead! Every time you make the client do the work, you slow down progress.
  3. Talk Short. Like this.
  4. Write for Handheld. You have to assume what you’re writing is being read on a tiny screen while multi-tasking. Get to the point fast and try to limit the need for scrolling.
  5. Always Go Up. The more senior the contact, the more real the deal. It doesn’t always make it more likely to close (although it helps), but it certainly limits being blindsided by information you weren’t aware of or the inability to get senior signoff.
  6. Never Stop Hunting.  Sales is not a downtime business.   If you’re sitting at your desk waiting for the next move from a client, you’re wasting time.   Do some research, find someone to call, make a connection.
  7. Pause.  If you keep talking, many people won’t interrupt you, even if they have a question.  One question unanswered could be the insurmountable hurdle for a deal.
  8. Don’t Be Annoying.  If you have a sales rep who is annoying, get rid of them.  If you are annoying, go get a life coach – being in sales is not for you.
  • Share/Bookmark